The sentence at hand:


I assume なんて here serves a derogatory role as など does in the following sentence:


As far as I know, the particle can be removed without significantly changing the meaning of the sentence completely or making it ungrammatical.

However, if we remove the particle from the first sentence, we have the following noun phrase.


As this is the first time seeing a question modifying a noun, this looks rather odd to me. I would have probably inserted a という or って in between.

  1. Is this a common construct? Can questions modify nouns other than こと?

  2. Would it also be correct to insert という or って in there? If so, how would the meaning change?

  3. Perhaps this getting is off topic, but are my observations regarding なんて・など accurate?

1 Answer 1



Your intuition is correct, this phrase is ungrammatical. You must insert という or って (サンタクロースをいつまで信じていたかということ).

According to a dictionary:

3 ある事物を例示して、次の語と同格であることを示す。…などという。「田中―人、知らない」「人間―ものはちっぽけなもんです」

So when なんて directly modifies a noun, you'd have to think of it as など + という. (田中など人 or 人間などもの are also ungrammatical)

  • Ah I see! Thanks! As I was taught, など, なんか, and なんて were treated as the same concept, so I had assumed that they were similar grammatically.
    – seafood258
    Commented Jan 16, 2016 at 0:43

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .