2

The following is an excerpt from an explanation by my language partner about the difference between "simple past" 送りました and 送っておきました。 She discussed a situation where she first sent me new-years stickers on Skype before sending me another message on italki where she talked about her sending the stickers on Skype before sending the message on italki with a 送っておきました construction.

「送りました」 の場合、過去形になっているので、メッセージを書くよりも前に送ったことになりますが、メッセージとの関係は示されていません。

I think that よりも前に means something along the lines of "from before", although I don't really know what this も does here. My attempt at translation:

In case of '送りました', because it is past form, even though it takes the meaning of having it (=the Skype stickers) sent from before writing the message, it doesn't demonstrate the relationship with the message.

2 Answers 2

6

メッセージを書くよりも前に送ったことになりますが、

The 「よりも前に」 means "before" or "earlier than". (より means "than", and 前に means "earlier".)

You can rephrase the sentence without changing the meaning:

メッセージを書くより前に送ったことになりますが、
メッセージを書く前に送ったことになりますが、

"although it would mean that (I) sent it before writing the message, ..."

「より前に」 sounds more explicit than just 「前に」, and 「よりも前に」 sounds a bit more emphatic than 「より前に」/「前に」.

As for the も:

よりも〘連語〙⇒ より(格助詞)
(明鏡国語辞典)


Sidenote: You can't replace より(も)前に with 前に when it follows a noun, e.g.

「山田さんより(も)前に着いた。」(×山田さん前に着いた。)
"I arrived before Yamada-san. / I arrived earlier than Yamada-san."

1

The function of 「よりも」 in this case would indicate a meaning of 'more than', or 'even more ____ '.

The use of も to mean 'even' is demonstrated below:

Aをしても Even if I do A.

Aでもない Not even A.

それよりも, A. Even more than that, A. /// Rather than that, A.

My interpretation of what your language partner was saying would be:

As regards my use of 「送りました」, as it is in the past-tense form, I was indicating that I sent them (the stickers) EVEN before composing a message, not referencing the actual message.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .