Skip to main content
1 of 3
naruto
  • 336.5k
  • 13
  • 339
  • 660
  1. 月日経つのは早いものだ。
  2. 月日経つのは早いものだ。

These sentences are syntactically exactly the same. Changing の to が doesn't change the meaning of the sentence a bit. The particles after 月日 are subject markers, and 月日{が/の}経つ is fundamentally a relative clause that modifies の (which is a noun).

Have you wondered why there is something called "ga-no conversion" in modern Japanese? You may believe が is the subject marker and の is the genitive case particle, but this distinction is rather new. In the past, these were almost the same particle. Both could mark a subject, and both could work as a possessive particle.

Although が and の have become very different in modern Japanese, this is why they are still interchangeable inside "relative clauses".

And the concept of "relative clauses" is a bit broader than the English equivalent. What you know as nominalizers and cleft sentences are actually a special type of relative clauses! Ga-no conversion works also inside these constructions, as shown below (S = subject marker, A = attributive form of a verb/adjective/copula, N = modified noun):

  • 太陽S昇るANを見ていた。
    太陽S昇るANを見ていた。
    I was watching the sun rising.
  • S来るANは知らなかった。
    S来るANは知らなかった。
    S来るAことNは知らなかった。
    S来るAことNは知らなかった。
    I didn't know that he would come.
  • S知っているAことNを教えてください。
    S知っているAことNを教えてください。
    Please tell me what he knows.
  • 彼女S1読んだA1N1は表紙S2赤いA2N2です。
    彼女S1読んだA1N1は表紙S2赤いA2N2です。
    It is a red-covered book that she read. (cleft sentence)
  • 月日S1経つA1N1S2早いA2ことN2S3嫌いなA3理由N3S4分からないA4N4S5したA5質問N5
    月日S1経つA1N1S2早いA2ことN2S3嫌いなA3理由N3S4分からないA4N4S5したA5質問N5
    a question made by someone who don't understand the reason why some people dislike the fact that time passes quickly

Notice the S-A-N pattern seen consistently in these examples. Don't mix the の as a subject marker (marked with S) and の as a formal noun (marked with N).

So, after looking at these examples, haven't you started to think it's not very meaningful to treat one as a subject marker and the other as a genitive case particle?

naruto
  • 336.5k
  • 13
  • 339
  • 660