2

luffy

I think I understand the general idea but I have trouble with the construction of this sentence. The situation is that he injured himself earlier and now he's tired. I guess he's saying something like "I shouldn't have injured myself", but I have two questions:

  1. Why is まで used here? Can we replace it with another particle like を?
  2. Why is 頼む added at the end? Can't we just end with までしたのに?

1 Answer 1

3

If I remember correctly, Luffy cut himself with a knife to show that he had the enough courage to join Shanks' party, right?

まで here is to indicate 極端な例 (see 1-4) of the act of 頼む. A full unfolding of the phrase would be 今日は顔にけがをしてまで頼んだのにシャンクスは航海に連れて行ってくれない.

(Edit: It may be that まで should be understood as indicating 動作の及ぶ範囲, but the explanation below remain more or less valid.)

A possible difficulty is that injuring oneself is not usually a way of asking. But in this scene, getting injured is actually to show the courage, so put it more verbose, 今日は顔に怪我をしてまで自分(=Luffy)の勇気を示したのに・・・.

So the sentence translates like Even though I injured myself (to show the courage) and asked to take me to the sea today(, Shanks didn't agree to do so).

===

Hopefully the following examples help:

  • 昨日は徹夜までして探したのに見つからなかった : Even though I searched without sleeping yesterday, I didn't find it
  • 親に借金までしたのにうまくいかなかった : Even though I borrowed money from my parents, it didn't work out.
  • 彼女と別れてまでアメリカに来たのに結局何も得られなかった : Even though I came to US leaving my girlfriend, I got nothing in the end.
2
  • I see that's not how I interpreted it. Is that a common use of まで?
    – Simon
    Jul 31, 2021 at 13:48
  • See also the edit. Anyway the idea is that in 'Xまで(して)Yする', X is something one normally does not (like to) do, but that is what s/he does in order to achieve Y. The phrase itself is fairly common. There are several particles for this kind of 極端な例, e.g. detail.chiebukuro.yahoo.co.jp/qa/question_detail/q126897902. To differentiate them grammatically seems rather difficult for me.
    – sundowner
    Jul 31, 2021 at 13:57

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .