3

In studying words like 羨ましい and 勇ましい, I've noticed that there are almost always corresponding (mostly transitive) む verbs:

羨む -> 羨ましい
勇む -> 勇ましい (transitive version seems to be archaic)
好む -> 好ましい
etc.

Is there any information on the background/connotation of this pattern? How far does it generalize?

4

Old and Classical Japanese adjectives

Let's look just at the ones that end in ~い in modern Japanese, classed as 形容詞【けいようし】 in mainstream Japanese-language grammars. This includes the ~ましい adjectives you mention in your question, while excluding ~な adjectives (technically 形容【けいよう】動詞【どうし】) like 静【しず】か or 大胆【だいたん】.

The Japanese Wikipedia has a brief description of these in the 古典【こてん】日本語【にほんご】の形容詞【けいようし】の活用【かつよう】 section of the 形容詞【けいようし】 article. This explains that ~しい adjectives are called シク活用【かつよう】 (-shiku conjugation) adjectives, from the way these conjugate in the adverbial form, contrasting with ク活用【かつよう】 adjectives. Both of these had the 終止形【しゅうしけい】 or terminal (sentence-ending) form ending in ~し, making them hard to differentiate just based on the 終止形.

How the シク活用【かつよう】 adjectives and ク活用【かつよう】 adjectives differ

Apparently the シク adjectives often described emotional or subjective qualities, things like "fun" or "reliable", while the ク adjectives described more physical or objective qualities, things like "red" or "big".

Derivations

This gets more to the meat of your question.

The Japanese Wikipedia article linked above doesn't really discuss derivation. Broadly speaking, after researching the etymologies of individual terms, it seems like many (most?) of the シク adjectives are derived from verbs, potentially from the causative form. Examples:

  • 羨【うらや】む "to envy" → 羨【うらや】ます "to make someone envy" → 羨【うらや】ましい "having the quality of making someone envy": "enviable"
  • 寄【よ】る "to draw close" → 寄【よ】らす "to make someone draw close" → 宜【よろ】しい "having the quality of making someone draw close" (the older sense): "desirable", then leading to modern "good"
  • 疑【うたが】う "to suspect" → 疑【うたが】わす "to make someone suspect" → 疑【うたが】わしい "having the quality of making someone suspect": "suspicious"

I wonder if this might have developed as a straightforward shift in usage of the 連用形【れんようけい】 of the causative: //-asi// is the 連用形 ending for the causative, and it's also already the 終止形 ending for many of these シク adjectives.

Irregularities: vowel shifts

Some of these derivations involve as-yet-unexplained vowel shifts, where the //a// in the regular causative becomes //o// in the adjective. Yoruyorasuyoroshii is one such example. 頼【たの】む → 頼【たの】ます → 頼【たの】もしい is another.

Speculation: //a// for external qualities, //o// for internal qualities?

Poking around on my own, I've encountered various term clusters where there appears to be an ancient //a// ↔ //o// alternation. Broadly, the //a// variant seems like it describes some kind of outward or extrinsic quality, while the //o// variant describes an inward or intrinsic quality.

Examples seem to show up in both the first and second vowels of various word pairs:

  • //hVs-//
    • //has-//, the root underlying はさむ and possibly 端・橋・箸: describing a narrow distance between two things externally
    • //hos-//, the root underlying ほそい: describing a narrow distance between the two edges of a thing internally
  • //tVmu//
    • たむ, earlier form of modern verbs たまる and ためる: something collects outwardly, like a puddle
    • とむ, something collects inwardly, enriching a thing
  • //komVru//
    • こまる, something gets stuck
    • こもる, something goes into something else
  • //kurV//
    • くら, "darkness", something that appears dark
    • くろ, "black", something that is intrinsically dark
  • //tubV//
    • つば, a swordguard, physically an outward protrusion
    • つぼ, a basin, physically an inward protrusion

I wonder if the shift to //o// that can be seen in some シク adjectives might be part of this, suggesting a more intrinsic or internal quality.

Irregularities: roots

Not all シク adjectives are traceable to verbs. Some シク adjectives come from reduplicated forms, like 長々【ながなが】しい or 馬鹿馬鹿【ばかばか】しい. Some come from mysterious roots: 楽【たの】しい is a good example. So far as I'm aware, there is no attestable verb たぬ.

General trends

That said, if a given シク adjective ends in -ashii or -oshii, and it's not obviously from a reduplicated root, chances are good that it might be from a verb. Look for a related verb form in the dictionary, based on the part before that -ashii or -oshii ending -- this could be a good opportunity to expand your vocabulary. :)

7
  • I feel the evidence for the /a/-/o/ external-internal distinction you presented is quite compelling, but couldn't e.g. 宜しい or 頼もしい be due to assimilation as well?
    – Sam
    Dec 3 '20 at 20:23
  • I may be way off the mark, but do you think that 楽しい may have come from [使]{し}む? 楽しい、悲しい、苦しい、親しい、怪しい、愛しい all have -む ending verbs 楽しむ、悲しむ、苦しむ、親しむ、怪しむ、愛しむ. It almost seems like these are derived from [使]{し}む, but it could also be the other way around and [使]{し}む could be derived from the シク活用 adjectives. I might be way off the mark, since しむ is 二段 and these む verbs are 五段. Do you think you could elaborate on this? Dec 3 '20 at 21:30
  • @Sam, assimilation is a possibility. However, there's the counter-example of 好【この】ましい, where the -ashii form is not just well-attested, but also the mainstream form -- in contrast to 頼【たの】もしい, where the oshii form is the mainstream, and the -ashii form is hard to find. This might fit the semantics: one finds something preferable from an external standpoint, whereas whether something is reliable or not is often a matter of some more intrinsic quality (arguably, anyway). Dec 3 '20 at 21:34
  • 1
    @EiríkrÚtlendi: thanks for your informative explanations as always Dec 4 '20 at 0:14
  • 1
    @EiríkrÚtlendi Fair point with 好ましい! Also, even though it might be bad SE form, I also would really like to thank you for your incredibly detailed explanation! I've already made a bunch of flashcards from it, so it won't go to waste! ;)
    – Sam
    Dec 4 '20 at 0:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.