Was practicing and came across some examples of saying what you are.



However, they explained that you cannot say the following:


It would have to be gakusei desu. Why is that? they are both nouns correct?

If i were to guess, it would be because if you are a student, it is constantly, where as if you are a nurse, its something you only do a few hours a day for work?


It's because this type of する means "to work as ~", "to play the role of ~".



娘, 子供, 赤ちゃん and so on are not the name of a role/occupation, so you cannot use する with them. 主婦をしている is okay if you think it's your job.

学生をしている is a gray area case and sometimes people say this as a response to "what's your job?", but it's usually safer to avoid it in a plain self-introduction.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.