3

I don’t get how "日本語が上手になるように毎日勉強しています" (日本語が上手になる) is a non-volitional verb/uncontrollable verb (Uncontrollable Verb - 雨が降る can’t control when it rains. 朝になった can’t control time) I understand that "早く良くなるように休んでください" (早く良くなる) is a non-volitional Verb since you can’t control how someone recovers but why can’t you control becoming/be better at Japanese by studying? For example: "医者になるために毎日勉強しています" (医者になる)become a doctor by studying/going to a medical school.

4
  • Can you explain what you mean by "uncontrollable verb"? I've never encountered this terminology before. Also, in your first sample sentence, the speaker is describing what they are doing, not what they will maybe do in the future: they are studying, and the ~ように describes they're goal for doing so. Nov 18 '20 at 17:45
  • In addition, I think we might have another terminology mismatch in your use of the word "volitional". I'm most used to hearing "volitional" used to describe the volitional or intentional or presumptive conjugation form of Japanese verbs, things like 行【い】こう for "let's go" or "[PERSON] will probably go", or 飲みましょう for "let's drink" or "[PERSON] will probably drink". In your use of "volitional", it sounds instead like you're talking about a class of verbs? Could you explain that better? Nov 18 '20 at 18:03
  • What I mean by volitional Verb is something called 意志動詞 and non volitional verbs - 無意志動詞
    – Alex
    Nov 18 '20 at 18:08
  • 1
    I'm not sure if this might help, but as I've understood it, なる is generally not anything related to volition or intent, even in English -- something just becomes. In your sample sentence, the embedded 「日本語【にほんご】が上手【じょうず】に[な]{●}[る]{●}」 is a hoped-for consequence of 毎日【まいにち】勉強【べんきょう】しています. Nov 18 '20 at 18:45
6

Volitionals and Non-Volitionals

意志動詞【いしどうし】 and 無意志動詞【むいしどうし】 are verbs that have "volition" or verbs without "volition". Volition in this context is the ability of the agent to control the action. In a volitional verb, the verb is an expression of the agent's will. Non-volitionals, on the other hand, are verbs that are not controlled by the agent and occur spontaneously. Volitionals verbs must be used with agents that have a "will" they can impose, like people, animals, or personified objects.

Do not confuse this with 他動詞【たどうし】(transitive verbs) and 自動詞【じどうし】(intransitive verbs). Although a large majority of 意志動詞 are 他動詞, some are not. Here are some examples:

落【お】とす - Transitive, volitional
座る【すわる】 - Intransitive, volitional
落ちる【おちる】 - Intransitive, non-volitional

になる

So where does になる fit into all of this? Well, it seems to have a special place depending on the context. For example, the phrase 「先生【せんせい】になる」makes なる a verb of volition while 「病気【びょうき】になる」 makes it a non-volitional. The reason for this is you cannot control whether you "become sick" or not. An easy test for this is adding ください to the end.

先生【せんせい】になってください
Please become a teacher.

This is a perfectly valid sentence. Whether you do or do not become a teacher is under your own control.

病気【びょうき】になってください
Please get sick.

This is grammatically incorrect. You do not control whether you get sick or not. If someone asked you to "get sick" the best you could do is probably sit in the rain and hope you get sick. You are not in control. The article I referenced seems to agree with this notion, but apparently there are scholars who disagree as well, because you could technically ask someone to at least try to get sick.

I want to say that this topic is sometimes debated, and as @Eiríkr Útlendi has demonstrated in the comments, なる is often listed as an example of 無意志動詞.

There are definitely other verbs can be both volitional and non-volitional. For example, in 「家【いえ】をでる」, 出る【でる】 is volitional. However, in 「水【みず】が出る【でる】」, 出る is non-volitional.

なるために、なるように

From what I have learned, ために is only used when the clause before it is directly controlled by the speaker. It is an expression of the agent's will. The clause before ために must express volition. On the other hand, the clause before ように should not express volition of the agent (Emphasis on "agent". ように may express volition of a different subject—please see the comment section). Finally, agent of the first clause in a sentence using ために must be the same as the agent of the second clause.

A more intuitive way to explain this is that ために implies full control of the situation while ように implies that the agent does not have full control. Here are some examples from Chiebukuro:

医者【いしゃ】になるために、一生懸命【いっしょうけんめい】勉強【べんきょう】しています。◎
医者【いしゃ】になるように、一生懸命【いっしょうけんめい】勉強【べんきょう】しています。×
Study hard to become a doctor.

The second sentence is incorrect because なる here is a volitional. You control whether or not you become a doctor, so this can only be used with ために. As for 上手, 「日本語が上手になる」 makes なる a 無意志動詞 because 日本語 becomes the agent of the verb, which cannot have volition since it is an inanimate thing.

日本語が上手になるために、一生懸命【いっしょうけんめい】勉強【べんきょう】しています。☓
日本語が上手になるように、一生懸命【いっしょうけんめい】勉強【べんきょう】しています。〇
In order for my Japanese to get better, I am studying my hardest.

Another reason why this first sentence is invalid is because the agent of the first clause (日本語)is different from that of the second (私).

More Examples of 意志動詞 and 無意志動詞

ある=無意志動詞
いる=意志動詞
喧嘩【けんか】をする=意志動詞
できる=無意志動詞
寝る=意志動詞
出す=意志動詞

Related Posts: なります intransitive verb - volitional/non-volitional

6
  • Clearly and cogently explained. +1 Nov 19 '20 at 0:14
  • Thank you so much!!
    – Alex
    Nov 19 '20 at 4:17
  • 3
    "The clause before ために must express volition while the clause before ように must never express volition." But there is exception, for example if the subject is different in the purposive and the main clause, even if both verbs are volitional there is no choice but use ように Nov 19 '20 at 7:45
  • 2
    @ThomasPetit I think I get what you're trying to say. For example in 「子供が壊さないように高い所に置いてください」, you are using a volitional verb, but the only choice is ように here. Maybe a better explanation would be that the first clause must not express the volition of the agent of the main clause. I also want to note that the ように I am referring to is only the one used to express that A is a goal achieved indirectly through B (AようにB).
    – Shurim
    Nov 19 '20 at 8:30
  • 「学生が教養を高めるように大学は図書館を充実させる」is the sentence I saw to illustrate that point. 高める and 充実させる are both volitional. Btw It come from this really nice paper (page 35 for the above example) openresearch-repository.anu.edu.au/bitstream/1885/132953/2/… Nov 19 '20 at 8:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.