2

I know that by attaching か、も、でも to the end of an interrogative word can form a new meaning, but if particles are also used, where should the position of each thing be?

Example:

Which day?
いつの日?

Some day...
いつの日か…

But, "Until someday" should be which of the following?
いつの日までか OR いつの日かまで?

Also, I have the impression that counters work differently than these interrogative words. For counters, it's always 「counter」+「か、も、でも」+の+「noun」, unless counter is used after the noun. For example:

With some students:
何人かの学生と ✅
何人の学生かと ❌
何人の学生とか ❌

Buy however many cars:
何台でもの車を買う ✅
何台の車でもを買う ❌
車を何台でも買う ✅

On some websites:
いくつかのウエブサイトで ✅
いくつのウエブサイトかで ❌
いくつのウエブサイトでか ❌

Am I correct about these? Or the ones that I think are wrong are in fact correct?

2

"Until someday" usually has to be いつか来る日まで or いつか来るその日まで. いつかの日まで is also used, but this is uncommon in my opinion. Alternatively, if you know what will happen on that day, you can use the corresponding verb and say something like this:

  • さようなら、いつかまた会う日まで。
  • この悪魔がいつか復活する日まで、私はこの門を守り続けます。

何台でもの車を買う is a wrong sentence. Otherwise your chart is okay.

Buy however many cars:

何台でもの車を買う ❌ ← !
何台の車でもを買う ❌
車を何台でも買う ✅
何台でも車を買う ✅

| improve this answer | |
  • Thanks, but 何台でもの車 on its own is still wrong? What if I don't want to say 'buy', just the 'however many cars' part? – David X Oct 6 at 1:11
  • @DavidX 何台でもの車 is wrong on its own. In other words でも doesn't work as a no-adjective. As you probably know, English prefers using adjectives to express numbers, but Japanese prefers adverb-based expressions. It's hard to translate 'however many cars' on its own. – naruto Oct 6 at 1:15
  • So でも is not used the same way as か?何台かの車 would be correct but 何台でもの車 would not be? Thanks for answering; I'm really trying to figure out how all these words falls into place just so I can combine them and say more complicated things. – David X Oct 6 at 1:18
  • @DavidX Regardless of question or not, も and でも (along with は, さえ, しか etc.) make the phrase work as (in English grammar terms) sentence adverb, not adjective. They can't modify nouns. か is better deemed as affix (like some- in "somewhere", "somehow") rather than particle after a noun. – broccoli facemask - cloth Oct 6 at 5:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.