I have read that verbs in Japanese are a closed class. That is to say: not counting inflections, there is some relatively fixed number of "true verbs" in the language. By "true verbs" I am excluding compound verbs formed with [noun]+する, or really [noun]+[verb] of any type. If this is the case, surely there is some estimate of roughly how many such verbs exist? I believe that i-adjectives are also a closed class, and I'd be curious about their number as well.
1I've heard of these, but I've usually seen them mentioned as exceptions rather than standard cases. Which is why I said "relatively" fixed number.– M. SperlingSep 1, 2020 at 17:58
3I’m voting to close this question because it is too broad. I don't think there's any way to know this.– istrasciSep 1, 2020 at 18:47
4Something is either 'fixed' or it isn't. Saying 'relatively fixed' doesn't make sense when you are asking if something is either closed or not, to be honest. As pointed out above, there are new verbs and adjectives being added, demonstrating that neither are a closed class. You can't accurately quantify an ever-changing quantity.– kandymanSep 1, 2020 at 19:02
1I mean, if you really need me to, I can try to link to some of the linguistic literature describing Japanese verbs as a closed class. As with everything in linguistics, it's a spectrum. For example, English prepositions are a very prototypical example of a closed class, but a new preposition still enters the lexicon every so often. Language is messy and there's always some level of "background noise" interfering with any categorization. But time and time again in the literature I've seen Japanese given as an example of a language with a closed class of verbs, so it seems fairly established.– M. SperlingSep 1, 2020 at 19:14
1I'd disagree with that literature then. New verbs are not that uncommon. Consider クッキングる ("to cooking", intentionally odd), スタバる ("to go to Starbucks"), ヤフる ("to search for something on Yahoo"). Verbs are not a lexically closed class in Japanese. There are not tons of new entrants, simply because most verbal concepts already have a word for them. But as new verbal concepts arise, so too do new verbs to express those concepts.– Eiríkr ÚtlendiSep 1, 2020 at 21:24
Coining new godan verbs (u-verbs) is far from exceptional in modern Japanese, and we have many related questions on this site.
- What are the principles behind turning foreign language words into verbs?(e.g. ググる and サボる)
- Characteristics of 'loan word root + る' verbs
- Can you form verbs from 擬態語 or 擬音語 by adding -る?
- Meaning and validity of 雪ってる
- What does ゴリってる mean?
- Pronunciation Troubles with トラブル and トラブる: Loanwords with both noun and verb ending in ru mora
I listed some well-known ones in the comment section, but just to support this, here are some rare u-verbs I happen to know personally:
- ジャムる: "to be jammed" (gun, military jargon)
- ばみる: "to use plastic tape to mark the positions of actors on stage" (actor's jargon)
- メタる: "to defeat an opponent with the aid of metagame" (card gamer's jargon)
- アポる: "to develop a brain infarction" (medical argot)
- サチる: "to saturate; to reach the limit" (data scientist's jargon)
- マミる: "to be decapitated" (anime fan's jargon)
- タヒる: "to die" (from the bottom part of 死)
- へごる: "to say something funny unintentionally" (Ayaka Ohashi's fan's jargon)
- ジュレる: "to be half-frozen" (leaves, gardening jargon)
Okay, these are used only in small communities, and I think less than 10% of native Japanese speakers know them. But I believe words like these are coined almost every day somewhere in Japan, and this is exactly why u-verbs are productive in Japanese.
On the other hand, the number of Japanese 助動詞 is relatively small and you can see the full list in Japanese Wikipedia.
Anyway, if you want a rough estimation, according to this page, the number of Japanese verbs listed in a certain dictionary is 10,265 (but this should include lexicalized compound verbs like 取り戻す). 国研日本語語彙DB recognizes 236 i-adjectives, but according to this page, the number of Japanese i-adjectives recognized by ATOK9 is much larger (1,302). 『品詞別日本文法講座4 形容詞・形容動詞』 by Suzuki et al lists 1,343 i-adjectives (and archaic precursors).
EDIT: I should've mentioned this... Ichidan (ru-) verbs are "relatively closed". According to this page, there are only 40 ichidan verbs that end with -iru (excluding compound verbs and archaic verbs).
1I’m really surprised ジャムる is rare, and that you’ve listed it as military jargon. I heard it many times in office settings in Japan in the 1980s, always in reference to printers and copiers. Sep 2, 2020 at 19:08
1@Nanigashi Personally I have heard only 詰まる for such situations, but there can be workplaces that have used ジャムる since the 80s. So this is another reason why u-verbs are "open" :)– narutoSep 2, 2020 at 21:13
1Yes, exactly! :) Sep 3, 2020 at 20:54