0

Would you leave 'you' out of translating this sentence?

"Money's worth what you make it worth."

So would お金は価値を持ってそれを作るものをの価値がある。be correct and still make sense?

Or would you have to put in some form of you, like そなた?

お金は価値を持ってそなたそれを作るものをの価値がある。

Or お金は価値を持ってあなたそれを作るものをの価値がある。

Situation is talking casually to acquaintance by email.

  • そなた is somewhat comparable to 'thou'. Where did you get the idea it was an ordinary way to say 'you'? – Aeon Akechi Jul 5 at 3:26
  • Regardless of casualness, it depends on whether you intend to say it as a personal advice or a generic remark. – broccoli facemask - cloth Jul 5 at 3:28
  • 1
    I have to say neither translations are grammatical – nodakai Jul 5 at 3:30
  • a generic remark – Eriek Jul 5 at 3:43
3

This type of "you" is called generic you. As you have guessed, how to express generic you depends on the language. In Japanese, it's often best not to specify a subject at all. 人 is a word that can be used to explicitly refer to generic you. あなた/そなた almost never appears in traditional Japanese sayings, but it may be understood in a translated material.

  • 欲しいものが常に手に入るわけではない。
    You can't always get what you want.
  • 何が起こるか分からない。
    You never know what will happen.
  • 人はパンだけで生きるのではない。
    Man shall not live by bread alone.

Your translation attempt has a number of grammatical errors. Most importantly, "to make it worth" cannot be expressed with 作る which only means "to create/establish/make". You have to use a causative form instead. A literal translation would be something like お金には人が価値を持たせる分だけの価値がある, but this still sounds fairly unnatural in Japanese. I recommend rephrasing it like お金の価値は使い方で決まる, 使う人によってお金の価値は変わる, うまく使えば使うほどお金の価値は上がる, etc.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.