1

In these two sentences, I would've thought に would be used in place, but instead を is used? When is it appropriate to use either?

A: 反対側【はんたいがわ】50メートルあたり探【さが】して! Search around 50 metres on the opposite side!

B: もし会【あ】ったらグレースどうするつもりですか? What are you planning to do to Grace if we see her?

Shouldn't be used in both of these to indicate the direction?

  • 3
    If your native language is English: is A really that unusual? Even in English, "search" can take the thing you're searching as a direct object. I.E. "Search your closet for clothes", "search the room for clues", etc. – Mindful Jan 17 at 4:04
4

Well, generally every language has some quirks in its grammar, but as for your examples, を is the only option and に is never used. I sense from your statement "I would've thought に would be used in place, but instead を is used" that you may think or be taught that case particles each represent some kind of "universal" trait, but they are actually decided by loose conventional rules much like English choice of prepositions, that you can't make nearly perfect prediction from its meaning.

A: 反対側50メートルあたり探して!

探す indeed has two kinds of noun alignment: [target]を[place]で探す and [place]を探す but neither can take に. You wouldn't see it except as a part of adverb: 効率的探す.

B: もし会ったらグレースどうするつもりですか?

Don't be fooled by the English translation. The answer you expect for "What do you do to Grace?" would usually not be "I do [noun] to Grace." but "I [verb] Grace.", isn't it? In that case, you use the phrase "do what" to asking another verb; it is a pro-verb, more specifically, interrogative verb.

English speakers have to work around the lack of pure interrogative verb by forming an expression "do what" (i.e. "what" as dummy object) and push the original object out as indirect "to" argument. Japanese doesn't have one either, but fortunately we have どうする (どう is an adverb) that doesn't take up the object slot, so that the true object remains the object.

グレースどうするつもりですか? vs What are you going to do to Grace?

グレース家に帰します vs I will send Grace back home.

| improve this answer | |
1

I read that に is used for indicating places of existence, target recipient [of something], the occasion, or the source of receiving an item. (There may be some I have missed.) I also read that を is for objects of a transitive verb (meaning a verb that needs something to receive the action it indicates). If I remember or know correctly, の is used before a prepositional noun like 横{よこ}(side)、近{ちか}く(near)、東{ひがし}(east)、南{みなみ}(south)、北{きた}(north)、or 西{にし}(west) in examples such as フィリピンの南{みなみ}(South of the Philippines)、日本{にほん}の北(North of Japan)、電車{でんしゃ}の近く(Near the train) 、 etcetera. I hope this helps.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.