In the story I'm reading the author use 「しまう」 as isolated word, in quotes:




I'm not sure about their meaning, and why they are in quotes.

As far as I know, 「しまう」 means "To finish, To stop, To do completely", so I was wondering about it showing the ability of the protagonist to play those music pieces. So, the second quote would mean something on the line of "When Mitsunori became able to play well that old Japanese music, one day his father Kiyoshi secretely brought him songs music scores and asked him "So, what about these? Are these 'I can do'?" (not sure about 「なんと」's meaning).

If I'm right, the other sentences should mean something like:

  • 最近ではついにオリジナル『しまい』始めたのだ: "Lately he had suddenly started to be able to play original pieces";
  • 二人でかわるがわる彼が『しまって』いる物語について熱心に教えてくれた: "The parents in turn told with enthusiasm to the boy stories in which he was able to do [what he was doing]".

Am I right? If so, why the quotes?

  • 1
    Could you confirm if there's no particle between オリジナル and 『しまい』? Jan 8 '20 at 8:18
  • There is 「で」, sorry, I missed it while transcribing; I'm not sure about its meaning, since I think my original reading ("started to be able to play old Japanese music") would require 「を」.
    – Mauro
    Jan 8 '20 at 8:43

As you know, this story is about a family who possesses a one-in-a-ten-million (and almost unhuman) kind of 'photographic' memory. Its members are capable of thoroughly memorizing massive and endless amounts of literature.

To describe their own special ability or action, they needed a word to use among themselves or use a common existing word for their own personal meaning. That word happened to be 「しまう」, which already had the meaning of "to stow away". You memorize 800 pages of information within days and stow it away in your brain just like an average person stows away a CD or something.

(You seem to be thinking of the meanings of 「しまう」 when used as a subsidiary verb.)

For the highly special, specific and private meaning of the word, therefore, the author had no choice but to put it in quotation marks.

For most native speakers, however, 「しまう」 should be a very natural word choice for the purpose. I never found it strange even for a moment while reading your question. Had the author selected a big Sino-loanword instead, however, I would have felt less "comfortable". That is the power of kana words.


EDIT: See l'électeur's answer. With the full context and the title of the story, it's clear that this しまう is a simple transitive verb that means "to put/keep/store (in a drawer, closet, box, etc)". This meaning of しまう is very common and not dialectal at all, but "brain" is not a container normally used with this verb, hence the brackets.

What the repeated double-square-brackets (『』) suggest is that the author knows this is an unusual, unnatural, peculiar usage of しまう, but he/she wanted to use しまう like this for some reason. Maybe this is natural in some dialect? Anyway, it's invalid at least in modern standard Japanese, and you should not try to use しまう like this.

Still, we can easily guess the meaning of しまう intended by the author is either "to finish/complete" or "to work on" depending on the context. Actually, this type of simple transitive しまう was actively used more than 100 years ago, and I vaguely remember I have heard this usage from old speakers many years ago.

なんと is explained here.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.