I have recently come to the conclusion that the N1 に N2 construction (eg パンにバター)is more common than I thought. It is the only explanation I think of to make grammatical sense of the sentences below. Could somebody confirm I have this right (in bold) in the following case?

なお、本状と行き違いにお支払い済みの場合はお許しください Please ignore this notice if you have already paid (this card and your payment have crossed)


The following sentence has been removed as に should have been の:相手に言い分もわかったとはいえ、心から納得したわけではない ( "Although I understand were he's coming from, I can't really agree with him.")

  • 1
    What does Sentence 1 mean? I think that it doesn't make sense. Who is the subject of 分かった? What you considered as the N1 に N2 construction is usually a phrase with omission of a verb. パンにバターをぬる makes パンにバター, which comes from パンにぬる and バターをぬる.
    – Gradius
    Aug 26 '12 at 1:20
  • 1
    – user1016
    Aug 26 '12 at 1:35
  • comment 1: Chocolate & Hyperworm are quite right, it should be の. I checked the source. Thanks. This sentence now makes sense.
    – Tim
    Aug 26 '12 at 2:09
  • Comment 2: @Gradius This use of に is still a problem for me. I've made a new question to keep things clean.
    – Tim
    Aug 26 '12 at 2:17

It's not an instance of the listing に.

Here に indicates that (と)行き違い describes the manner in which お支払い(済み) was done.

Please forgive us in the case that payment has been completed "in crossing" with this letter. (=while the letter was still on its way... I'm not sure you can use this form for this in English, I might just have made "in crossing" up)

I think it's the same as this に, despite お支払い済み appearing not to be a verb...

And ringing the bell in passing, he led the way into the adjoining room.

  • Comment3(contd from above): @Hyperworm: Tx: This is grammar I can't find in text books, hence the guesses. Can に act as a adverb with verbs such as those above and perhaps 擦れ違い or is this possibly a variation on 「本を買いに行く」
    – Tim
    Aug 26 '12 at 2:50
  • I have removed sentence one from my question. I shall probably put my new questions into a new one, with an appropriate q-title, you can get the credit for this one. Tx
    – Tim
    Aug 28 '12 at 15:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.