1

As far as I know all じる verbs are supposed to be 一段.

I found an interesting set of rules online:

Does the verb end in る?
No → 五段
Yes → Does it have an e or i sound before the る?
No → 五段
Yes → Is the e or i sound part of the okurigana of the verb?
Yes → 一段
No → Could be both.

And someone posted the following counter examples to rule 3:

混じる (まじる)
脂ぎる (あぶらぎる)
捩じる (ねじる)
抓める (つめる)

So I looked it up and found a few explanations for why these aren't valid examples.

脂ぎる seems like it's just 脂 + きる (unsure which kanji).
捩じる is 捩る or maybe some funky 二段/四段/s-irregular stuff. (Still wondering though, because じる was made for 一段.)
抓める is 抓る.

I found that 混じる can also be 混る, but that spelling is listed in no dictionary.

So am I just ass-pulling stuff, or is the rule wrong or is まじる really special?

  • The version of the rule I saw pointed out that it applies only when you have at least 2 kanji in the stem (e.g. 見る is out). – Mathieu Bouville Feb 12 at 8:31
  • 3
    You can think as you like. There's no rule to begin with. – user4092 Feb 13 at 7:31
2

Many on-reading + じる verbs are indeed ichidan verbs, e.g., 信じる, 感じる, 念じる, 演じる. This じる is etymologically just する. Note that these verbs have zuru-ending variations like 信ずる. See: Origin of 信じる, 感じる, etc?

However, まじる has nothing to do with this rule. まじる is a plain godan verb whose stem happens to include じ. Likewise, かじる, もじる and ねじる are godan verbs.

There is a rare verb こんじる, which is also written as 混じる in kanji. Since こん is an on-reading, this conjugates as an ichidan verb, and has a variation, 混ずる(こんずる). This is used only in highly stiff documents.

混る【まじる】 is a rare spelling variant of 混じる【まじる】, and it's perhaps considered nonstandard by today's standards. Omission of okurigana has nothing to do with the type of the verb. See: What's the difference between 落す and 落とす?

-2

I don't know about the rule but 混じる does conjugate like a ichidan verb.

混じます, 混じない, 混じて

If it walks like a duck ...

Weirdly, on jisho.org it says its a godan verb but with inflections like an ichidan verb

  • 2
    If you visit the Jisho.org entry here and click the "Show inflections" button on the upper left, you should see only godan inflections. The ichidan inflections are for the 混【こん】じる reading, a separate word. – Eiríkr Útlendi Sep 5 at 18:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.