2

I read this sentence in another post:

でも貝のかんじにもうひとつのいみをつけます。
But we will assign another meaning to the kanji 貝.

Putting aside any other problems with this sentence, I feel that もう一つ isn't the right word to use for 'another' in this context. I may of course be wrong, but I would have gone with 別の or 他の instead, but I can't explain why (maybe because I'm talking nonsense).

Anyway, I'm now wondering what the difference is between もうひとつ, 別 and 他 when used to mean 'another'.

1 Answer 1

2

I think the difference is subtle here.

もうひとつ means another by way of meaning one other or one more.

別 can mean another by way of meaning different.

他 is probably the truest sense of the word another, but there are cases where you'd use one of the other two in a more natural context.

In the sense of the given phrase, I think all three utterances work equally well:

でも貝のかんじにもうひとつのいみをつけます。
でも貝のかんじに別{べつ}のいみをつけます。
でも貝のかんじに他{ほか}のいみをつけます。

If もうひとつ was chosen here it was merely because it is probably the first of the three phrases to be introduced in a textbook.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .