3

In this sentence:

「もしもし、今、駅に向かって(_______)ところです。 あと5、6分でつきます。」

What should be the correct tense of the verb 歩く? Should I base my answer on the word 今 or the てform of 向かう?

If there is 今 does that mean that た+ところ is not appropriate?
If I see a Verbてform, all my V should be in てform?

Thank you

  • To clarify: do you want to add the verb 歩く into the blank? – mamster Oct 14 '18 at 3:48
  • Yes sorry. The verb is 歩く – Shiniboi Oct 14 '18 at 6:03
4
  1. 今、駅に向かって歩いているところです。
    I am walking toward the station. (i.e. I am on the way.)
  2. 今、駅に向かって歩くところです。
    I am just about to walk toward the station. (i.e., I have not departed yet.)
  3. 今、駅に向かって歩いたところです。
    I have just walked toward the station. (i.e., I have finished walking.)

These three sentences are all at least grammatical, but Sentence 1 is the most natural. Sentence 2 is not entirely wrong, but people usually say something like 今から出発します if they have not departed yet. Sentence 3 doesn't make sense at all in this context.

The existence of 今 is not really important because these sentences describe his current situation even without saying 今 (Note all the sentences end with です, which is the present tense). Even in sentence 3, it describes his current situation. It's similar to ている describing the continuation of state, except that the original action happened shortly before now (hence "just").

Related:

  • Thank you. I am having problems choosing the best answer 😭 Thank you for your help. – Shiniboi Oct 14 '18 at 6:05

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.