I have the following situation in some fiction I'm reading. Person B comes to a world looking to do something. Person A arrives afterward looking for B. As soon as A arrives she starts monologuing about probable B's intentions. Something along the lines "She'll first go for 'group of people' and after contacting them she'll go for 'Plot relevant thing' that somehow ended up here and try to acquire and bring it back home."

After recounting what she thinks B's plan/objective (目的) is she says the following line:




As of now it seems she is saying:

Up until that method/plan it's undecipherable (the rest of the data) but it seems plain that it B couldn't have gathered this much info on so far away a world alone...

The thing that bothers me is that その方法までは because I'm not sure what that is supposed to convey. I'm assuming that その方法 is the plan she just described. And so she is basically saying that everything before that plan in the database is unreadable. But it kinda feels strange to say UP UNTIL in this kind of context.

So, am I right oooooorrr.....


その方法 should be simply "the method for (achieving) that". So there is a contrast between "the plan (itself)" and "the method to complete the plan". In other words, she's saying she could decipher what B wanted to do, but not how B could achieve it. (I'm assuming the context you provided is reliable. If you want ask about what その refers to, please do not omit the previous sentences in Japanese...)

This まで is "to the point", "as far as", "to an extent". In positive sentences it can be simply translated as "even". See this.

  • Soo made here is kinda for fluff reasons maybe. Kinda like "As far as the method for that goes I couldn't decrypt it" vs. "I couldn't decipher the method"? And the literally first line before this was "これがおそらくBの目的" which came after she described what that plan could be. – 4th Dimension Sep 17 '18 at 14:03
  • 1
    @4thDimension So, she could decipher to the extent that she understood the purpose, but not to the extent that she understood the method. – naruto Sep 17 '18 at 15:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.