I'm reading a book, and the antagonist was released from prison early because he bribed the district prosecutioner.

The main character says: 野郎。。。 法なんてあってねーようなもんじゃねーか

This is my translation: Bastard... It's like there is no law (lacking in lawfulness?)

But I'm not sure how もんじゃない functions here. I know もんだ/です can function as giving a reason for something. Is もんじゃない used similarly but ない is used because it is a negative verb?


Your translation attempt is spot-on.

This もん is a simple noun, "thing". あってないようなもの is a set phrase that means "a thing that exists but is like nonexistent," or "a thing that's virtually nonexistent". It's commonly used to describe how something is useless or meaningless.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.