3

I am doing an exercise in Genki Book I. The question is:

Translate "I don't think Chieko likes Mayumi" into Japanese.

I think the answer is:

ちえこさんはまゆみさんが好きじゃないと思います。

Is the meaning of this Japanese sentence ambiguous? Could it instead mean that Chieko thinks Mayumi doesn't like (something)?

If I wanted to include 私は, to make it clear that this is my opinion, what happens with the particles in the rest of the sentence? Does the は after ちえこさん become が? Is this the only thing that changes?

私はちえこさんまゆみさんが好きじゃないと思います。

Is this correct?

6

"I don't think Chieko likes Mayumi."

Your TL of that is:

「ちえこさんはまゆみさんが好きじゃないと思います。」

Your translation is good if the purpose of the lesson is to learn to use 「思う」 in the affirmative form even though the sentence in question is clearly in the negative form "I don't think".

As a Japanese sentence, it is impeccable. Its meaning is not ambiguous at all unless you say it in a situiation where talking about who Chieko likes or dislikes is clearly irrelevant. Japanese is an incredibly contexual language; Take that from a veteran native speaker.

If you wanted to use 「私は」, I would suggest you place it right in front of the verb at the end instead of at the beginning of the sentence. That would be:

「ちえこさんまゆみさん好きじゃないと私は思います。」

It is, of course, grammatical to say:

私は、ちえこさんまゆみさん好きじゃないと思います。」

Mentioning all three persons at the beginning makes it look/sound kind of crammed, which is why I used a comma after the 「私は」.

「私は」 is not required at all in Japanese though it might take time for you to get used to it.

Could it instead mean that Chieko thinks Mayumi doesn't like (something)?

Again, it could if it is said in a situation/context where the topic of the discussion is who likes or dislikes something (instead of who likes or dislikes someone), which is why I have to type the same sentence here everyday: "Japanese is a contextual language".

The exact same phrase/sentence can mean completely different things.

Finally, your sentence:

「私は、ちえこさんまゆみさん好きじゃないと思います。」

means a different thing than:

「私は、ちえこさんまゆみさん好きじゃないと思います。」

To say the former sentence, you need to have been talking about multiple people who might or might not like Mayumi. Then you are saying that out of all those people, it is Chieko who does not like Mayumi.

To say the latter, no particular context is needed. You are just saying that Chieko does not like Mayumi.

If nothing I am saying makes sense to you, do not worry too much about it now. You will get used to our particles in a few years. As if I had met someone who had mastered the particles in a few years...

| improve this answer | |
1

For it to mean "Chieko thinks Mayumi doesn't like something". You would need all はs in the sentence, because が denotes the object of "like". So, 私は好き does not mean "I like myself", but would instead mean "I like [it] (the object which is liked is omitted). 私は犬が好き "I like dogs". Now in this sentence you have an object (I keep saying object but the correct term would be subject...) to be "liked".

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.