1

What makes 飲んだ、and 飲んである different?

Don't they both describe the concept of drinking in the past?

More generally, what are the differences between the past tense of a verb, and the auxiliary verb ある?

  • 3
    I'll just put this in the comment. But if you want in the answer, that's ok with me. 飲んだ means drunk. I drank the milk, for instance. ~てある describes a resulting state with the agent who causes the change being de-emphasised (perhaps they are/it is unimportant). 窓(まど)が開(あ)けてある The window is open (has been left open). 窓 takes が, which makes it the subject. The agent is left out. If I was the one who left the window open, this fact is completely ignored. The statement is just matter-of-fact and my involvement is completely de-emphasised. – Robert May 14 '17 at 2:08
  • 1
    Related (or duplicate?) japanese.stackexchange.com/a/26132/9831 – Chocolate May 14 '17 at 2:51
1

Where does 飲んである come from? I can't think of any legitimate construction off the top of my head. 飲んでいた?

飲んだ is the simple past of 飲む. 飲んでいた is the past progressive or past perfect.

[Later edit] The context for 飲んである is like 冷蔵庫に入ってる牛乳が飲んであった?

Then this 飲んで is a 連用形 word modifying ある and the subject is 牛乳 (and naturally, the subject of 飲む is someone who drank it)

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.