4

The scenario: Two people looking at a picture of their deceased relative.

Person 1:

はぁーあ、こんな遺影じゃおちおち感傷にも浸れない

Which I believe translates to:

I shouldn't get sentimental so carelessly over something like a picture

Person 2:

確かにコレじゃあなー

This response is confusing me, if 確かに means "certainly", コレ means "this" and じゃあなー means "isn't it/right?" then that would would mean it literally translates to "certainly this isn't it", I know I shouldn't think of things too literally but I'm at a loss as to what it could mean in a more contextual sense, can anyone please explain what it actually means?

4

The conversation suggests there is something amiss about that particular photo, which makes it difficult for them to indulge in sentimentalism as they like.

Person 1 goes like this:

Man, with his/her portrait like this, it's impossible to get properly sentimental.

Person 2 agrees:

Yeah, not with (the portrait like) this.

Notice that the じゃあ is the same thing as the じゃ in Person 1's line. It's the colloquial contraction of the compound particle では, made up of で(with) + は(topic marker).

3

You have mixed up じゃねえ and じゃあなー. In speech ない contracts to ねえ/ねぇ/ねー, but never to なあ/なぁ/なー (except in Nagoya dialect where ない sounds similar to なぁ /næː/).

So this literally translates to "Certainly, with this, <something negative left unsaid>." A possible translation would be "With this...yeah." or even "You can say that."

By the way こんな遺影 is "a portrait (of deceased person) like this", not "something like a portrait". And why is おちおち translated as carelessly?

1

Its picture was so terrible.

That's right. (This picture is too bad to get sentimental. Although I dare not to say, but you are aware of my opinion, aren't you?)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.