1

Using the hiragana practice and katakana paractice Google Play apps as a reference,

why is the stroke order of the cross in あ、お、か、き、け、さ、す、せ、た、な、は、ほ、ま、む、や、よ、ら、を is first horizontal, then vertical, (like in the Chinese 十 (shi2) (ten)), whereas in ね、も、れ、わ it is vertical and then horizontal?

  • 5
    Maybe because it's easier to write. – user4092 Oct 12 '16 at 9:56
3

Firstly, for ね、れ、わ, the second stroke isn't really just a horizontal stroke, so it's unfair to compare it to あ. The second stroke of ね、れ、わ goes on to change direction and curl later on. Try doing the second stroke first then aiming the vertical stroke. Your mileage may vary.

Then for も, in its katakana form モ has the horizontal stroke first. I refer you to this question: Why is the stroke order of も peculiar?

3

Stroke orders of hiragana are ultimately based on the stroke orders of kanji from which they derived. Unfortunately, each kanji has its own history, and it's hard to generalize how the stroke order of each kanji was determined. Similar-looking kanji can have different stroke orders (see this for example), and these are basically something you have to memorize via practicing.

What's worse, the stroke order of a single kanji may be different between 草書 (cursive script, which hiragana are based on) and 楷書 (regular script), and average native speakers of Japanese (including myself) do not know how to write with 草書 today. Only trained calligraphers and researchers understand the essence of 草書.

So it would take you years to truly understand "why". I would recommend you learn hiragana without thinking about the origin too much, just as elementary school kids do in Japan.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.