4

I'm trying to determine natural way(s) to express how certain Chess moves will be advantageous or disadvantageous in a certain position.

In this position, if you exchange your queen with your opponents rook, you'll be at a disadvantage.

This is my best guess at how to express this:

この局面ではクイーンと相手のルークを交換したら損するよ。

Other things I can think of are

〜しないほうがいい
〜得はしない
〜立場が悪くなる
〜困る

If anyone knows of how I can express getting into a "bad situation" or "a loss" in this context, I'd appreciate it. Other words I might be able to use are 有利 or 不利.

  • You could find some examples looking through annotated games such as this one. – bcloutier Jul 21 '16 at 18:28
  • Thanks, that is a good reference. However, it looks like the style of speech is a bit different than a person might use when casually speaking, so if anyone knows any simple expressions that don't make me sound like an announcer, that would be good too. – Locksleyu Jul 21 '16 at 18:49
  • The example sentence seems a little unnatural, not linguistically but game-wise, I guess you wanted to say "you'll be simply at a disadvantage" or so. If so, I'd go with クイーンとルークの交換は単に損だ. – user4092 Jul 22 '16 at 15:42
  • @user4092: So my example is grammatically correct but doesn't fit the game? How is the meaning of my sentence different from yours? (I mean the "クイーンとルークの交換" part) – Locksleyu Jul 22 '16 at 16:49
  • I meant queen-rook exchange is disadvantageous by default and you won't take that move unless you will get some benefit in another aspect, so if you are to comment something, you'd point out short of that exchangeable benefit. – user4092 Jul 22 '16 at 20:34
5

The expressions you listed all seem fine to me. But there are other expressions that can be used, with different nuances. These are used mainly for shogi moves, but I believe you can use them also for chess.

Using jargon, in the order of severity:

  • ~は大【だい】悪手【あくしゅ】だ
  • ~は悪手【あくしゅ】だ
  • ~は疑問手【ぎもんしゅ】だ
  • ~は緩手【かんしゅ】だ

More vaguely:

  • ~は味が悪い
  • ~はよくない
  • ~は苦しい/~は(後で)苦しくなる
  • ~は緩い
  • ~はぬるい

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.