3

Reading Tae Kim's guide, I've seen the phrase:

誰が盗んだのか、誰か知りませんか

Where (I think) the term 誰か is being used as topic for the verb 知る.

Is that grammatically correct ?

  • 1
    What do you mean by "topic" in your question? (wikipedia has a lengthy article on topic vs. subject en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topic_and_comment). – virmaior Jul 20 '16 at 23:46
  • @virmaior Most likely the OP is mixing up subject and topic. – snailcar Jul 21 '16 at 4:57
  • It's more like "does anyone know?" vs "does someone know? anyone?" – larvyde Jul 21 '16 at 9:08
  • @snailplane, I completely misunderstood the notion of "topic". I should have said "subject" to express what I intended. The points of confusion are not seeing を marking the direct object of 知る and not seeing が indicating that 誰か is the subject. – Vitor Arruda Jul 22 '16 at 2:41
2

I don't know 誰か is used as topic but 誰か知りませんか? is common and I think that is grammatically correct.

It is translated as "Does anyone know ~?" and your sentence is "Does anyone know who stole?".

0

It's because it's the most straightforward choice.

Using は would sound as if you are wondering if there's at least one person who knows it among people present there, and using が would sound as if you are wondering if there's a person in the world who knows it.

Incidentally, the topic of the whole sentence is 誰が盗んだのか, (edit) that's why it's not marked with を.

-2

Both が and か could be used after 誰. However their functions are different as follows:

  1. が indicates 'sentence subject'. "誰が盗んだのか" literally translates to "About who stole (something)".

  2. か also indicates 'sentence subject'. However, it has connotation of uncertainty and doubt. "誰か知りませんか" literally translates to "(I am not sure whether somebody could find out who stole it), but does anybody know?"

Other examples:

誰か来たようだ I am not sure who came, but I think somebody came.

むこうに誰かいる I am not sure who there is, but I think somebody is there.

  • let me check if I got it right: Even though は or が usually mark the subject of the sentence, the particle か in the phrase I mentioned is the one indicating 誰 as subject ? – Vitor Arruda Jul 22 '16 at 2:43

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.