12

A couple of times I've tried to say "I agree with..." or "he agrees with..." but I don't know whether I'm using 同意{どうい}する correctly.

In what ways should に同意{どうい}している be used? Also, which particles should be used? Can only be used before 同意{どうい}する or are there circumstances where other particles are used as well, such as and ?

In many examples I've found using 同意{どうい}する, I've seen (だ)ということに or just (な)ことに (the / after na adjectives/nouns and without / after i adjectives/verbs it seems.) Is there a specific reason for using one over the other, e.g. is the longer (だ)ということに more polite, and what do these mean?


Some example sentences:

  • I agree with his opinion:

    彼{かれ}の意見{いけん}に同意{どうい}します。

  • I agree with him that oranges are tasty:

    オレンジはおいしいということ彼{かれ}に同意{どうい}します。

  • He agrees that apples are tasty:

    彼{かれ}はりんごがおいしいことに同意{どうい}します。

  • Many people agree that brussel sprouts don't taste nice:

    芽{め}キャベツはおいしくないということに同意{どうい}する人{ひと}が多{おお}い。


See also: What are the different ways of saying to agree or disagree with a person? for other ways of agreeing/disagreeing with someone.

8
  • 4
    I think 賛成 has the added meaning of "approve"
    – Flaw
    Oct 16, 2011 at 3:26
  • 2
    I think a common one is 同感【どうかん】. It seems to be a little "softer" and more familiar than 同意【どうい】.
    – istrasci
    Oct 16, 2011 at 3:39
  • 1
    The example オレンジはおいしいだということに彼に同意します is totally ungrammatical. 芽キャベツはおいしくないだということに同意する人が多い is ungrammatical unless you are referring to some non-standard dialect.
    – user458
    Oct 16, 2011 at 5:36
  • 2
    For オレンジ..., you cannot have two ...に phrases. Remove either. And for the two sentences that I mentioned, remove だと.
    – user458
    Oct 16, 2011 at 7:53
  • 1
    @DavidMorrissey Your editing is right. I should have said to remove . Sorry.
    – user458
    Oct 16, 2011 at 15:50

1 Answer 1

3

You can find a lot of examples here (you may want to check later pages), which will explain a lot.

It seems that we do use "に" for "同意する".

"ということ" literally means "the so-called", which I think is a little more polite.

Also to @sawa, search in the above site with "いという" and "いだという" (I know they are not words nor phrases ...) gives interesting results. It seems that wile i adjectives, "美味しいだということ" can be used.

And I think "オレンジはおいしいということ彼に同意します" is still a little weird, maybe it should be "オレンジおいしいだということについて彼に同意します。". A phrase with nothing in the end doesn't sound natural. (About "は" and "が", I just feel this way, I am not able to explain it in details.)

BTW, I am not native, so correct me if I am wrong.

2
  • 「おいしいということ」 is ungrammatical. Should be 「おいしいということ」.
    – Chocolate
    Jul 27, 2020 at 15:52
  • "いだという" ... gives interesting results <- 「形容詞+だという」の例はありませんが。。
    – Chocolate
    Jul 27, 2020 at 16:09

You must log in to answer this question.