9

I have found this sentence in Odin Sphere. I guess it's kind of old fashion for a strong interdiction. I first thought it came from the negative form of である but it doesn't seem to be replaceable by ではない.

Does anyone know the origin of this form?

7

Yes, ~するでない is an old-fashioned and pompous way of saying "Don't do ~!".

In modern Japanese, this is a kind of 役割語 (stereotyped role words) which is typically used by noble and/or old people in manga and samurai dramas. This seems to have been used a lot more 100 years ago or so, because I can find many similar expressions (eg. 泣くでない, 穢すでない, 淋しがるでない) in 青空文庫.

As for the etymology, unfortunately I could not find a good article which explains this. One answer in this chiebukuro question says:

原型となったのは江戸時代の上方語です。

So it seems to have originated from somewhere in Kansai region in the Edo period.

In this question two people say it's 江戸時代の武士の言葉, but I don't know whether real samurai in the Edo period actually spoke in this way.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.