So, I've been told by a native Japanese that the following sentence sounds weird:

  • LA VITA E'BELLAを見{み}る[時]{とき}、[感動]{かんどう}しました。

In her own words, 'because watching that video is a one time thing and not your habit, so we usually use the past tense.'

But in my book, it says that in a A時、B sentence, we use the present short form when A happens after or at the time of B. And I want to say that I got emotional when I watched that film (at the same time, not after the film). So, could anybody explain to me in more detail whether the sentence is correct or not, and why?

  • That's a good movie!
    – istrasci
    Aug 27 '15 at 15:10

When you are moved by a movie, you have already watched the movie. You remember the scenes, music, and the story.


implies when you were moved, LA VITA E'BELLA hadn't finished yet. So it sounds like you were moved by something else (such as equipment of the theater or behavior of the audience) during the movie or just before it started.


This means that you had watched LA VITA E'BELLA when you were moved, that is, you were moved probably by the movie itself.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.