I was talking to my friend, and she said
きれいにとれた！
What does に after an adjective mean, or what does に before a verb mean?
And where can I read more about this?
Thank you
Add a comment
|
1 Answer
In this case, doesn't に just make きれい (a な adjective) an adverb?
きれいにとれた
You were able to take it beautifully.
-
-
2You are bringing English grammar into Japanese. In Japanese, no matter how you conjugate an adjective, it still remains an adjective as a part of speech.– user4032Commented Jul 20, 2015 at 21:37
-
@l'électeur Very interesting. I'm by no means a competent speaker of Japanese and I only answered this question because I was pretty sure I understood the sentence. You don't by any chance know of any source where I could read about Japanese grammar from a Japanese point of view without imposing English convention (written in English)? I feel such a perspective would greatly aid my study. Thanks!– G-CamCommented Jul 22, 2015 at 13:32
-
1@G-Cam The きれいに adjectivally modifies the verb 取れた, but きれいに is not an adverb but the ren'yo-kei (continuative form) of the na-adjective きれいな. (Have you learnt "ren'yo-kei"?)– chocolate ♦Commented Jul 23, 2015 at 9:40
-
@choco I've learned of the 連用形 in the context of verbs and verbal adjectives but not with regard to na-adjectives. My understanding was that it could be used to create compound verbs, connect sentences in a way similar to the te-form, or stand alone as a noun. So, in a phrase like "食べ過ぎる", is 食べ still considered a verb that "verbally" modifies 過ぎる? Thanks– G-CamCommented Jul 23, 2015 at 15:14