7

I don't understand the meaning of に in this sentence:

切り出すに切り出せず、今日まできてしまいました

Is 切り出すに切り出せず fashioned after some particular grammar? I can't really think of an interpretation that sounds natural.

5

「Verb + に(or にも) + Same Verb in potential form + ず」

is a very common phrase pattern that expresses one's inability or hesitation to perform the action described by the verb.

See 一-2 in: https://kotobank.jp/word/%E3%81%AB%E3%82%82-592921#E3.83.87.E3.82.B8.E3.82.BF.E3.83.AB.E5.A4.A7.E8.BE.9E.E6.B3.89

「[切]{き}り[出]{だ}すに切り出せず、[今日]{きょう}まできてしまいました。」

means:

"I have not been quite able to bring up (this) topic until today."

2

This is more of a grammatical construction where you have a verb in base form plus に followed by a negative potential form of the same verb. It basically means that for some prohibiting reason, you couldn't do ~~~ even if you wanted to.

終電を逃したから、帰るには帰れない。(Paraphrasing, "I missed the last train and I have no way to get home.")

It looks like in the sentence you shared, it would mean something like, "(No matter how much I wanted to) I had no way to bring it up..."

1
  • 3
    ×「帰るには帰れない」--> ○「帰るに帰れない」「帰るにも帰れない」「帰ろうにも帰れない」 or 「帰りたくても帰れない」 – Chocolate May 5 '15 at 8:27
2

Semantically, it means 切り出したかったのに切り出せず. (切り出す = to broach (a topic))

[dictionary form of a verb] + に + [nai-form] + ない is an uncommon, emphatic, and literary set phrase which means "want to ~ but can't", "too bad/extraordinary to ~", etc.

  • 泣くに泣けない状況 a situation too bad to cry
  • 笑うに笑えない話 a story too extraordinary to laugh at
  • この料理は食うに食えない this dish is too bad to eat (tastes awful)
  • 食うに食えない生活を送る have difficulty to live on (because of poverty)

I think this に corresponds to either of the two definitions of this page:

[格助]名詞、名詞に準じる語、動詞の連用形・連体形などに付く。
13 (動詞・形容詞を重ねて)強意を表す。「騒ぎ―騒ぐ」
「風いたう吹き、海の面(おもて)ただあし―あしうなるに」〈枕・三〇六〉

[接助]活用語の連体形に付く。
3 逆接の確定条件を表す。…けれども。…のに。…だが。
「日中の照りに乾いて、きょうは道が好かった―、小庭の苔はまだ濡れている」〈鴎外・蛇〉

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.