7

The correct stroke order of is apparently:

traditional stroke order of 凹

Is there any reason for this order? Why, for example, would one not write the vertical | stroke to the bottom right directly after the 3rd stroke, effectively reducing the stroke count to 4?

Same question for , the correct stroke order seems to be one of these:

two possible stroke orders for 凸 from a dictionary

(left: 新漢語林【しんかんごりん】, right: 新選漢和辞典【しんせんかんわじてん】)

So how did people come up with these stroke orders?

  • Based upon the question on word-reference and copied my answer there, because I thought it would be a good addition to this ite. – blutorange Nov 30 '14 at 9:09
4

The stroke order you mentioned is the correct one indeed. It can be found in the 新漢語林【しんかんごりん】, for example.

This page, kakijun, offers an explanation for the stroke order:

Traditionally, ie. based upon the 字彙【じい】 and 康熙【こうき】 dictionaries, is categorized under the 凵【かんにょう】 radical, so this part is written individually. is written with | stroke to the right last, as in or . The remaining part is written following the general principles left-to-right and top-to-bottom.

Remember that although there are rules and guidelines, the exact stroke order can involve some arbitrariness. The page linked above also mentions an alternative, more logical stroke order based upon the character's shape.

alternative stroke order for 凹

Same reason as above, it is categorized under the radical, and thus the top part is written indiviually. As can be seen in the image you posted, there is some variation to how the top part can be written, although the stroke order to the left with the vertical | stroke first seems to be more common, it is also the stroke order indicated by the 新漢語林.

This entry on akatsukinishisu mentions that there are some people writing and with one stroke as well. It also notes that uniquely shaped , categorized under the 十(じゅう) radical, is written with the part individually as well, giving some credibility to the explanation for and .

stroke order 卍, variation 1 stroke order 卍, variation 2

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.