How could I write about something in the future where something will have happened? That is, I'm writing from the perspective of the current time, about a perspective in the future where something has happened between the two perspectives.

My specific case right now is to get the equivalent of "If you are reading this, I will already be dead" in Japanese.
Currently I'm thinking of 「これを読んでいるなら、私はもう死んでいました」, but that seems to translate more to "If you are reading this, I am already dead", that is, the perspective for it is in the future, but I want to write in the present.

  • "If you are reading this, I will already be dead" ⟵ this
  • "If you are reading this, I am already dead" ⟵ not this

Since this is a bit hard to understand, here's a drawing to explain what I want to do:

Time ───────────────┬────────────────────┬────────────────┬─────────────>
        Now (Writing the letter)       I die        Letter is read
                    └────────────────┐   └────────────────│────────────────┐
                       Writing from here, talking about this, referencing this event

@YangMuye suggested turning it into a question: 「あなたがこれを読んでいるなら、私はもう死んでいるでしょう。」Would this be the best way to do it?

While also helping me with my specific case, please also give a general answer to the question in case people need to apply it to other sentences such as, "In the future, androids will have been created", or "At the heat death of the universe, all black holes will have evaporated" (Yes, I'm bad at examples)

  • +1 for the diagram alone.
    – istrasci
    May 13, 2014 at 15:33
  • 3
    OMG, you contrived to turn a simple translation question into a sophisticated linguistic one.
    – Yang Muye
    May 13, 2014 at 15:44

2 Answers 2


If you're sure you'll die and I'll read your letter after your death, then you'd say:

(Literally: I will already be dead when you read this letter.)

If I won't read your letter if you survive, then you'd say:

(Literally: If you're reading this letter, then it means that I'm already dead.)

If you're not sure that I'll read your letter, but you're sure that it'll be only after your death that I can read it, then:

(Literally: If you read this letter, it will be after my death.)

(Sorry if I'm misreading your question.)

  • 1
    What is wrong with 「あなたがこれを読んでいるなら、私はもう死んでいるでしょう。」/ "If you are reading this then I am probably dead."?
    – Tim
    May 13, 2014 at 16:09
  • 2
    読んだなら/読んだら/読んでいるなら~するでしょう/しているでしょう sounds to me like "If you do XX, then I'll do YY/I'll be doing YY." Like, "I'll die if you read it."
    – user1016
    May 13, 2014 at 17:27
  • 2
    死んでいるでしょう doesn't sound unnatural; I used it in my first and second sentences above.
    – user1016
    May 13, 2014 at 17:29
  • 1
    「これをあなたが読んだなら、その時、私は死んでいるでしょう。」>> I think 「これをあなたが読んだなら/読むとすれば、その時(に)はもう、私は死んでいるでしょう。」 would sound more natural and easier to understand.
    – user1016
    May 13, 2014 at 17:41
  • 2
    @Chocolate,@Yange Muye : I think a possible context is either a Will (遺言)or if a soldier writes a letter to his wife and then gives it to a comrade and says "please give this letter to my wife if I die". The OP's statement would appear in the letter. The writer uses "if you are reading this" rather than "if you have read this" because it gives the feeling of conversation to the reader and it it is irrelevant if she has completely read it. On the other "If you have received this letter" would be ok (because she would not receive it if the writer had not died)
    – Tim
    May 13, 2014 at 22:52

Temporal sequencing in Japanese is quite complicated so to answer your question I am going to simplify the sentence, if I may, to:

If you have received this letter then I have (already) been killed in the war.

(This allows me to avoid questions about the use of 〜ている and resultant state verbs which is also complicated and not the main point of your question. It is covered in other questions on this site.)

The た-form indicates that an action has been completed not that it took place in the past. If you use なら then the action becomes hypothetical in the sense that it may or may not happen, or have happend, which is the situation when the letter was written but not when the reader receives the letter. The important point is that in your scenario, if the first statement has come true then the second statement will also be true. The sentence would then be:


If you want to add "already" then もう can be inserted after 私は.

Needless to say, when making such a statement the context has to be clear for the reader to infer the correct meaning. And, as you can see from Chocolate's excellent answer, the exact wording will depend on what exactly you want to say but if you want to know how to make a simple statement about two future dependent hypothetical events then I think this is one model that should work.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .