Japanese Language Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students, teachers, and linguists wanting to discuss the finer points of the Japanese language. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
I was looking for the verb しゃべる in the dictionary, as it got me curious since I've only known 話す for a while.
In the dictionary there are two example sentences which look the same, but the dictionary gives two different meanings:
- 彼女はよくしゃべる。
She talks a lot.- 彼はよくしゃべる。
He talks well.
What? They look exactly the same to me, except the personal pronoun but why does the meaning changes? Is it a matter of "having both meanings" or what?
Those are just two different definitions of よく.
〔うまく・好ましく〕
- この作文はとてもよく書けている → This composition is very good [well written].
- 今日は大分気分がよくなりました → I feel much better today.
- 事態は一向によくならない → The situation has not improved at all.
〔しばしば〕- 彼はよく怒る → He often gets angry.
- よくあるケースだ → It's the kind of thing that happens every day. / That's (fairly) common.
- 僕が子供のとき，母はよく本を読んでくれた → When I was a child, my mother used to often read me books.
- 近ごろこの辺りはよく放火がある → There have been many cases of arson around here recently.
Of course without any context, it's not possible to know exactly which meaning is implied. From your examples, I immediately jump to the "often" definition. If you wanted to avoid confusion for just the neutral statement, you would probably change the first example to use うまく or 上手に instead of よく. But if you're in the middle of a conversation, the context is going to likely afford you the correct definition.
Of course, context gives it away, but I think that "speaking well" and "talking a lot" would usually be distinguished as
彼はよくしゃべれる。 He can talk well. = He is a good speaker.
彼はよくしゃべる。 He talks a lot.
Of course the first can also mean "He can talk a lot", but, at least for mem the second is almost unambiguous.
