Skip to main content
Commonmark migration
Source Link

I was re-reading my Genki text the other day regarding intransitive verbs and ている and it stated that when intransitive verbs take the ている form they exclusively refer to the state resulting from the change, i.e.

窓が開いている。
The window's open.

 

お湯が沸いている。
The water boiled.

However, with certain phrases such as 雨が降っている can the meaning be both 「It's raining/It has rained」 ? Which interpretation would be more appropriate 「It's raining」 or 「It has rained」? I would interpret it as 「It has rained」.

Is it a set in stone rule that all intransitive verbs take the result of change form rather than the "-ing/progressive form" or is this just loose rule genki introduced with exceptions?

I was re-reading my Genki text the other day regarding intransitive verbs and ている and it stated that when intransitive verbs take the ている form they exclusively refer to the state resulting from the change, i.e.

窓が開いている。
The window's open.

 

お湯が沸いている。
The water boiled.

However, with certain phrases such as 雨が降っている can the meaning be both 「It's raining/It has rained」 ? Which interpretation would be more appropriate 「It's raining」 or 「It has rained」? I would interpret it as 「It has rained」.

Is it a set in stone rule that all intransitive verbs take the result of change form rather than the "-ing/progressive form" or is this just loose rule genki introduced with exceptions?

I was re-reading my Genki text the other day regarding intransitive verbs and ている and it stated that when intransitive verbs take the ている form they exclusively refer to the state resulting from the change, i.e.

窓が開いている。
The window's open.

お湯が沸いている。
The water boiled.

However, with certain phrases such as 雨が降っている can the meaning be both 「It's raining/It has rained」 ? Which interpretation would be more appropriate 「It's raining」 or 「It has rained」? I would interpret it as 「It has rained」.

Is it a set in stone rule that all intransitive verbs take the result of change form rather than the "-ing/progressive form" or is this just loose rule genki introduced with exceptions?

Bumped by Community user
Tweeted twitter.com/StackJapanese/status/651296228320411648
edited tags
Link
user1478
user1478
edited tags
Link
user1478
user1478
deleted 1 character in body
Source Link
Earthliŋ
  • 48.4k
  • 10
  • 130
  • 201
Loading
Source Link
mattb
  • 1.8k
  • 2
  • 18
  • 31
Loading