Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackJapanese/status/310700497323577345
edited title
Source Link
user1478
user1478

The uses & etemologyetymology of で

In Japanese, the particle で seems to have multiple uses:

  1. Instrumental: 車{くるま}大阪{おおさか}に行{い}った。 "I went to Osaka by car."
  2. Locative: 図書館{としょかん}数学{すうがく}を勉強{べんきょう}している。 "I'm studying math in the library."
  3. て-form of copula: 水{みず}はきれい静{しず}かだ。 "The water is pretty and calm."
  4. て-form of copula (sentence conjunction): 彼{かれ}は来{く}るの、大丈夫{だいじょうぶ}だ。 "He's coming, so it'll be fine."
  5. 連用形{れんようけい} of copula: そうはない。 "That's not how it is."

(It may be possible to analyze #4 as a 連用形, in the 中止形{ちゅうしけい} sense, but I don't think that's what is in modern usage, since there is an implication of temporal order.)

What is the origin of these uses? Do all these でs historically come from one thing?

(I've heard that "で came from にて", but that doesn't really explain much for me in terms of how all these forms came about and if they are really all from the same original thing.)

The uses & etemology of で

In Japanese, the particle で seems to have multiple uses:

  1. Instrumental: 車{くるま}大阪{おおさか}に行{い}った。 "I went to Osaka by car."
  2. Locative: 図書館{としょかん}数学{すうがく}を勉強{べんきょう}している。 "I'm studying math in the library."
  3. て-form of copula: 水{みず}はきれい静{しず}かだ。 "The water is pretty and calm."
  4. て-form of copula (sentence conjunction): 彼{かれ}は来{く}るの、大丈夫{だいじょうぶ}だ。 "He's coming, so it'll be fine."
  5. 連用形{れんようけい} of copula: そうはない。 "That's not how it is."

(It may be possible to analyze #4 as a 連用形, in the 中止形{ちゅうしけい} sense, but I don't think that's what is in modern usage, since there is an implication of temporal order.)

What is the origin of these uses? Do all these でs historically come from one thing?

(I've heard that "で came from にて", but that doesn't really explain much for me in terms of how all these forms came about and if they are really all from the same original thing.)

The uses & etymology of で

In Japanese, the particle で seems to have multiple uses:

  1. Instrumental: 車{くるま}大阪{おおさか}に行{い}った。 "I went to Osaka by car."
  2. Locative: 図書館{としょかん}数学{すうがく}を勉強{べんきょう}している。 "I'm studying math in the library."
  3. て-form of copula: 水{みず}はきれい静{しず}かだ。 "The water is pretty and calm."
  4. て-form of copula (sentence conjunction): 彼{かれ}は来{く}るの、大丈夫{だいじょうぶ}だ。 "He's coming, so it'll be fine."
  5. 連用形{れんようけい} of copula: そうはない。 "That's not how it is."

(It may be possible to analyze #4 as a 連用形, in the 中止形{ちゅうしけい} sense, but I don't think that's what is in modern usage, since there is an implication of temporal order.)

What is the origin of these uses? Do all these でs historically come from one thing?

(I've heard that "で came from にて", but that doesn't really explain much for me in terms of how all these forms came about and if they are really all from the same original thing.)

Source Link
Darius Jahandarie
  • 16.5k
  • 4
  • 49
  • 114

The uses & etemology of で

In Japanese, the particle で seems to have multiple uses:

  1. Instrumental: 車{くるま}大阪{おおさか}に行{い}った。 "I went to Osaka by car."
  2. Locative: 図書館{としょかん}数学{すうがく}を勉強{べんきょう}している。 "I'm studying math in the library."
  3. て-form of copula: 水{みず}はきれい静{しず}かだ。 "The water is pretty and calm."
  4. て-form of copula (sentence conjunction): 彼{かれ}は来{く}るの、大丈夫{だいじょうぶ}だ。 "He's coming, so it'll be fine."
  5. 連用形{れんようけい} of copula: そうはない。 "That's not how it is."

(It may be possible to analyze #4 as a 連用形, in the 中止形{ちゅうしけい} sense, but I don't think that's what is in modern usage, since there is an implication of temporal order.)

What is the origin of these uses? Do all these でs historically come from one thing?

(I've heard that "で came from にて", but that doesn't really explain much for me in terms of how all these forms came about and if they are really all from the same original thing.)