981 reputation
221
bio website althack.org
location Storrs, CT
age 21
visits member for 4 months
seen 28 mins ago
stats profile views 24

Native English speaker, beginner in Japanese, but interested in Japanese grammar and historical Japanese linguistics.


Feb
5
comment What function did あり perform in classical Japanese 形容詞?
Thanks, this helps some. It does not make the 連用形 case so clear though. Why would the past tense be 熱かりたり rather than 熱くたり? (Are both forms valid in all contexts? I think I've only seen the former. But even so, why would there be a need for two?) --- Also, this suggests that ある is semantically vacuous and is only there for conjugations. I think this makes sense to me, since having a copula there would not really mesh with what I know about 形容詞 at least.
Feb
5
comment What function did あり perform in classical Japanese 形容詞?
I've modified it to say 「熱き」の連用形 since that certainly makes more sense than just having nothing there.
Feb
5
revised What function did あり perform in classical Japanese 形容詞?
This is probably better.
Feb
5
comment What function did あり perform in classical Japanese 形容詞?
@TsuyoshiIto Yes, you're right, but I wasn't sure if I should mark 熱く as 「熱き」の連用形 or not, because it seems like 熱かり is the 連用形 for most (all?) purposes. I'm not sure how I should note this in my deconstructions.
Feb
5
asked What function did あり perform in classical Japanese 形容詞?
Feb
3
reviewed Excellent Difference in nuance between 証明 and 証拠?
Feb
3
reviewed Satisfactory 「こわいだから。」 versus 「こわい、だから[…]」
Feb
3
reviewed Satisfactory How can I say “the leader(s) of the club” in Japanese
Feb
3
reviewed Needs Improvement What is the function of と in とある?
Feb
3
reviewed Satisfactory Is 以降 inclusive?
Feb
3
answered When should the polite form of 〜たり be used?
Feb
3
comment What suffix do you add to a verb to make it perfective or imperfective?
@EricDong た is simply past tense. Japanese does not have the perfect aspect (which is what I was trying to say in this answer). 食べていた is fine.
Feb
2
awarded  Custodian
Feb
2
reviewed Satisfactory How should I bid farewell to a superior?
Feb
2
awarded  Custodian
Feb
2
reviewed Leave Open Are there any Japanese words as versatile as “fuck” in English?
Feb
2
reviewed Close Is Japanese understandable without pitch?
Feb
2
reviewed Leave Open Did the Japanese have a word for surrender before WWII?
Feb
2
reviewed Leave Open What are the pronunciation differences between speaking and singing Japanese?
Feb
1
awarded  Critic