954 reputation
221
bio website althack.org
location Storrs, CT
age 21
visits member for 4 months
seen 5 hours ago
stats profile views 23

Native English speaker, beginner in Japanese, but interested in Japanese grammar and historical Japanese linguistics.


Apr
8
comment “太ってる猫” vs “太った猫”
This answer is not correct. 太った猫 does not necessarily mean that the cat got fat, it simply means it is fat. sawa's answer is correct.
Apr
8
comment Difference between progressive verb forms and i-adjectives
I don't think そのパンダは太っている necessarily means that the panda was once skinny and then got fat. It simply means it is fat. If you wanted to say "got fat" you'd say そのパンダは太った.
Apr
7
comment What is the etymology of 〜ません(でした)?
Thanks for the great answer. I'm somewhat surprised that there was no variation where ぬ itself was inflected... something like ませざりたり ⇒ ませざった (though I am not so sure of the interplay between ぬ and ず and if ぬ had its own set of inflections).
Apr
7
accepted What is the etymology of 〜ません(でした)?
Apr
7
asked What is the etymology of 〜ません(でした)?
Mar
28
revised What function did あり perform in classical Japanese 形容詞?
More examples to hopefully clarify why this confuses me. Many thanks to Tsuyoshi Ito.
Mar
28
reviewed No Action Needed なので relationship does not seem to match in そうじが楽なので、部屋にはなるべく物を置かないようにしている
Mar
27
comment Nominalization with のが、のを
@snailplane Yes. I'm not sure of all the rules, but I believe you'll only see something like that in: 1) a relative clause, like your example, where the subject can't be topicalized, so a double が marking would be rather confusing, or 2) in the subordinate clause of a transitive verb like 思う. To my knowledge, the object of 好きだ will never be marked by an を if it's at the top level of the sentence.
Mar
27
answered Nominalization with のが、のを
Mar
27
reviewed No Action Needed What was the base for Japanese numbers?
Mar
25
revised What's the difference between ことがある or ことはある?
Fix bolding.
Mar
25
answered What's the difference between ことがある or ことはある?
Mar
25
suggested suggested edit on What's the difference between ことがある or ことはある?
Mar
23
reviewed Leave Open Interpretation of a sentence by Mishima
Mar
21
revised Meaning of “何か来るんやろなとは思ったけどな”
added 41 characters in body
Mar
21
revised Meaning of “何か来るんやろなとは思ったけどな”
added 200 characters in body
Mar
21
answered Meaning of “何か来るんやろなとは思ったけどな”
Mar
20
answered What is an appropriate translation of 親和感?
Mar
18
comment Using と to mark a question
@Chocolate なるほどですね。まあ、どちらしても結局博多弁だったので、凄く感がいいと思います。
Mar
18
comment Using と to mark a question
@ssb Not from the provided clip, no, I don't think. I downloaded an episode of the anime to figure out which one it was. I'm not sure how Chocolate figured it out from the clip.