Take the 2-minute tour ×
Japanese Language Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students, teachers, and linguists wanting to discuss the finer points of the Japanese language. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In English (and, I assume, its relatives), there is a style of narration called free indirect speech, some examples of which are given in the linked article.

I'm having trouble figuring out whether or not Japanese supports something similar. Clearly, Japanese has direct speech (直接話法):

A: それはリンゴだ。
B: 「それはリンゴだ」とAは言った。

Japanese also has some sort of indirect/reported speech (間接話法):

A: それはリンゴだ。
B: Aによると、それはリンゴだそうだ。

Can Japanese do free indirect speech (自由間接話法, I guess)? What would that look like? I get the feeling that Japanese might not have a strong distinction between free and ordinary indirect speech, but am having trouble figuring out what the correct mapping between English indirect speech and Japanese indirect speech is.

share|improve this question
    
I think のでしょうか might have a more or less similar function. If the pronoun (A) does not appear, it's very common to temporarily switch the view point from the speaker to the person be talking about. This is often triggered by たら, と, some perception verbs like みる or verbs in the present tense. I don't know how exactly it works. –  Yang Muye May 22 at 8:29

1 Answer 1

  1. 彼はリンゴを見つめながら悩んだ。彼は、このリンゴを、今食べるべきだろうか?
  2. 彼はリンゴを見つめながら悩んだ。私は、このリンゴを、今食べるべきだろうか?
  3. 彼はリンゴを見つめながら悩んだ。「私は、このリンゴを、今食べるべきだろうか?」
  4. 彼はリンゴを見つめながら悩んだ。このリンゴを、今食べるべきだろうか?

If I'm not mistaken, you're asking whether the example 1 is natural in Japanese?

The example 3 is the simplest and of course good. The example 2 omits かぎ括弧 and looks perfect in novels. You can just omit the subject as in the example 4, and actually this is the most common way, I think.

And yes, the first example does make sense, and looks natural for me, at least if seen in serious novels. However it is the least common option of the four.

share|improve this answer
    
Uses too many commas (and pronouns) in the example sentences. –  非回答者 May 27 at 11:43

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.