Tell me more ×
Japanese Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students, teachers, and linguists wanting to discuss the finer points of the Japanese language. It's 100% free, no registration required.
up vote 4 down vote favorite

Is there one? One of my dictionaries lists them as

  • 欲{ほっ}する　→　to desire/to want
  • 欲しがる　→　to desire/to want/to wish for/to covet

Only the latter sounds like it includes more "bad"/selfish desires (covet). However, in this verse in the Bible, they both appear, and both talk about "bad"/selfishly desiring something.

あなたの隣人の妻を欲{ほっ}してはならない。隣人の家、畑、男女の奴隷、牛、ろばなど、隣人のものを一切欲しがってはならない。　―　 申命記 / 5章 21節

So all they really different at all?

Also, as a side question, is 欲する ever read as よくする? I see it listed here, and it comes up in my Android Google Japanese IME, but the dictionary only has an entry for ほっする.

share|improve this question
2  
Isn't 欲しがる for another person's desires? Maybe 欲する is for your own desires. – dotnetN00b Mar 9 at 4:04
2  
According to the excerpts from the 日国 entries on the page you linked, よくする means 欲をだす。よくばる。, which doesn't sound to me like it's quite the same as ほっする, which has one sense meaning ほしいと思う。得たいと思う。また、望む。願う。ほりす。. (That's all we can see in the excerpt, but 大辞林 lists a second sense.) It seems that they're different words with different origins. I assume you mean ほっする at the top of your question, but maybe you could add furigana to clarify. – snailboat♦ Mar 9 at 5:48
I think 「[欲]{ほっ}す(る)」sounds literary/archaic so we rather say/use「欲しがる」(in modern Japanese?), and「~~(せ)んと欲す」also sounds archaic so we normally say/use 「~~(し)たいと思う」「~~(し)たがる」. – Chocolate Mar 9 at 17:49

Know someone who can answer? Share a link to this question via email, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook.

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.